Coin Brief ENDE

Juicebox V6 under Glamsterdam rules: transactions succeed while payments inside them fail

Simulations of Juicebox V6 payment contracts under the rules proposed for Ethereum's Glamsterdam upgrade show transactions that succeed while a payment inside them fails, CryptoSlate reported on 17 November. The developer mejango ran the tests on 14 November on the Sepolia test network, using deployed contract code through eth_simulateV1: each simulation launches and funds a fresh project, then tests a payment path at different transaction gas limits, pinned to a block.

Four paths produced that outcome. A payout succeeded while skipping a split to another project, leaving the money in the paying project. A reserved-token distribution completed although a cross-project payment failed, and the beneficiary received raw tokens instead. A buyer kept an NFT while the associated payment to another project failed. In the cash-out test, gas limits sampled between 679,622 and 817,622 let the withdrawal complete without paying its 2.5% fee. The comparison runs against mainnet rules showed only transaction failures or complete delivery for all four paths.

According to the developer's explanation, the difference is which operation runs out of gas first. Under the tested rules, an internal payment that writes fresh storage can fail before the outer transaction does, and the contract's try/catch handling absorbs the failure and lets the outer operation finish. The rules in question are EIP-8037, which raises costs for creating persistent state and accounts for state creation separately from execution, and EIP-8038, which updates the costs of accessing and writing state.

The 16 November testing-call agenda lists Juicebox's compatibility concerns within the EIP-8037/8038 investigations. CryptoSlate notes the results are the developer's simulations, not independently reproduced, with no live incident. The Ethereum Foundation's 9 November update lists 19 November for discussing findings and possible next steps, with no decision precommitted.

Juicebox V6 under Glamsterdam rules: transactions succeed while payments inside them fail
Juicebox V6 under Glamsterdam rules: transactions succeed while payments inside them fail — Coin Brief

Why it matters

The examples turn a general warning about repricing state into specific outcomes in deployed code: a receipt that says success while a fee or a split was never paid. For contracts that cannot be changed in place, that is the question the 19 November discussion has to weigh.