Coin Brief ENDE

CFTC staff let clearing houses settle daily through trust companies, a path for crypto margin

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission's Division of Clearing and Risk issued a no-action letter on 5 November saying that derivatives clearing organisations may use trust companies for daily settlements with clearing members. Staff letter 26-30 responds to a request from Nodal Clear dated 29 October.

The issue is a gap between two sets of rules. The Commodity Exchange Act and the Commission's customer protection rules require customer funds to be held with a bank or trust company, but Regulation 39.14, which governs how clearing houses settle with their members, defines a settlement bank as a bank and does not mention trust companies. Nodal argued that trust companies are under comprehensive state supervision, citing New York, where banks and trust companies are chartered under the same banking law, and that the main differences are that trust companies generally do not take consumer deposits or make loans. It also stated that state-regulated trust companies are among the leading custodians of digital assets, and that clarifying the rule would help clearing houses accept such assets as margin within their existing daily workflows.

The Division's position is that it will not recommend enforcement against any clearing house that uses a trust company for daily settlements, provided it treats the trust company as if it were a settlement bank when complying with Regulations 39.14(c) and (d), the rules on selecting and monitoring settlement banks. The letter notes that Regulation 39.14 has not been substantively revised since 2011 and, as is standard, represents the Division's view only, not the Commission's.

CFTC staff let clearing houses settle daily through trust companies, a path for crypto margin
CFTC staff let clearing houses settle daily through trust companies, a path for crypto margin — Coin Brief

What it means

The letter does not mention any coin, but the plumbing it opens is the one digital-asset collateral needs: the custodian that holds the assets can now also be the settlement agent. It is a staff position, so it can be withdrawn, and a rule change would still be needed to make it permanent.